Shayla recommended a book called Spark, by Sarah Beth Durst. As I started reading it, I didn't really like it so much, and it was slow going. And then I finally got into it, and have completely changed my mind. It is about a 12 year old girl named Mina, who lives in a society in which certain child volunteers are given the egg of a storm beast, which they carefully tend and nurture for two years, until the egg hatches. Then they and the beast do training so they can help to control the perfect weather of their country, Alorria.
Alorria is like Camelot--"the rain may never fall til after sundown, by eight the morning fog must disappear"--plus more. Their lightning beasts harvest electricity. Their sun and wind beasts make sure they have just the right amounts of those, etc. They know that there are more people in other countries on the other side of the mountain, but they think they are poor pathetic people, quite inferior to themselves, and when they rarely think about them at all, they just pity them because they do not live in such a perfect place as Alorria.
The book, is to me, kind of an allegory. There are people in Alorria who are concerned about what they are doing with the weather--the sky is all connected, they say--so what we do must surely impact the outside world. But mostly, people don't care because their own little part of the world is so perfect.
So when Mina accidentally meets the prime minister, and asks this one undesired question, "Does the ten year festival cause the ten year storms in the outside world?" she quickly realizes that not only is the answer to her question yes, but the powers that be KNOW they do--otherwise, why would it matter if she asked the question?
Mina is suspended from lightning school for a week--mostly to protect her from scrutiny until the backlash from her question dies down--she goes home, and gathers the courage to speak to her family about why she is really suspended. When she tells them about the connection between the festival and the storms, this happens on pages 210-211:
Gaton (her older brother): Wait--you heard the rumors, too? And you asked the prime minister?
Papa: I'm sure you're mistaken. The storm beasts prevent storms, not cause them. What happens beyond the mountains has nothing to do with us.
Mother: You insulted the prime minister? She's a national hero! She isn't keeping secrets from her people! That's ridiculous!
Gaton: You're seriously brave. I've heard stories about the prime minister--she hates to be wrong. So you're saying this is why you were suspended?
Papa: The weather in Alorria doesn't cause deaths beyond the mountains. I think you're overreacting. Yes, there has been discussion--
Mother: Lies. The festival doesn't "kill lots of people" [It does.] Storm beasts keep people safe! That's the entire point of celebration! Haven't you read your history?
Gaton: History approved by the prime minister! All weather is connected--the sky is all one piece. You can't dismiss facts just because you don't like where they lead!
Papa: Now, now. I'm sure our government wouldn't deliberately lie. And I'm sure that there's another logical explanation for these "deadly storms."
Mother: If they even exist. Has anyone seen a shred of proof? All I've heard is talk from people who have never even been beyond the mountains. [Mina has been there.]
Gaton: Are you saying Mina's lying?
Papa: Of course no one is saying that.
Mother: I'm saying she's mistaken.
Gaton: She talked with the prime minister!
Mother: But she didn't see any proof--
Gaton: She doesn't need proof, she has logic!
Papa: Let's all calm down.
I don't know about you, but that whole conversation reminds me, well, of the world (country) we live in.
Later, on page 236, Eione, from the other side of the mountain, in not-Alorria says: "You have any idea what it's like to face a killer storm? [a dying economy, war right in your neighborhood, lack of water due to changing weather patterns, extreme heat, starvation--you can replace so many things with killer storm in that question.] No, of course you don't, because in Alorria you only have perfect summer days with mild wind and endless sunshine as you live your perfect, mild lives of endless selfishness."
Wow. Mild lives of endless selfishness. Huh.
On page 262, Mina converses with her teacher, Professor Dano, who is also concerned about the plight of the rest of the world in the face of Alorrian decisions.
Dano: My friends don't believe that children have learned empathy yet. You have at least proved them wrong in that.
Mina: Don't they remember being my age?
Dano: Just the bad parts. Children can be selfish creatures.
Mina: Adults can be worse. (The prime minister and her advisors, after all, were adults. They knew the truth and had the power to do something to help, yet they refused to.)
Dano: I can't argue with that...You must understand that this is about more than one celebration. If the prime minister acknowledges that the festival causes deadly storms beyond the mountains, then it opens the door to change. The prime minister would need to reevaluate every use of storm beasts. If the festival causes harm, what else does? How does keeping our fields perfectly watered affect the ousiders? Examining the effects of our actions could have ramifications throughout the entire economy. Alorria has been prosperous because of its carefully cultivated selfishness. What happens when that crumbles?
Another wow. Carefully cultivated selfishness. Huh.
Back to Eione on page 288:
Eione: I don't want their pity. I want them to stop murdering our people and destroying our homes. [Which they are doing indirectly through the truly savage weather that does indeed kill and destroy.] How's she going to convince them to do that? Look at these people, smug in their wealth, blinded by their excess. What is she going to tell them that's going to compete with all this?
Smug in their wealth. Blinded by their excess. Could this be...us?
Mina has Eione speak--she doesn't do it herself. And one last paragraph from page 291: Just because mountains [borders] surrounded them didn't mean they were separated from the rest of the world. They were part of the world. Their sky was also everyone else's sky.
So much "meat" in this juvenile fiction book! Comments?
Alorria is like Camelot--"the rain may never fall til after sundown, by eight the morning fog must disappear"--plus more. Their lightning beasts harvest electricity. Their sun and wind beasts make sure they have just the right amounts of those, etc. They know that there are more people in other countries on the other side of the mountain, but they think they are poor pathetic people, quite inferior to themselves, and when they rarely think about them at all, they just pity them because they do not live in such a perfect place as Alorria.
The book, is to me, kind of an allegory. There are people in Alorria who are concerned about what they are doing with the weather--the sky is all connected, they say--so what we do must surely impact the outside world. But mostly, people don't care because their own little part of the world is so perfect.
So when Mina accidentally meets the prime minister, and asks this one undesired question, "Does the ten year festival cause the ten year storms in the outside world?" she quickly realizes that not only is the answer to her question yes, but the powers that be KNOW they do--otherwise, why would it matter if she asked the question?
Mina is suspended from lightning school for a week--mostly to protect her from scrutiny until the backlash from her question dies down--she goes home, and gathers the courage to speak to her family about why she is really suspended. When she tells them about the connection between the festival and the storms, this happens on pages 210-211:
Gaton (her older brother): Wait--you heard the rumors, too? And you asked the prime minister?
Papa: I'm sure you're mistaken. The storm beasts prevent storms, not cause them. What happens beyond the mountains has nothing to do with us.
Mother: You insulted the prime minister? She's a national hero! She isn't keeping secrets from her people! That's ridiculous!
Gaton: You're seriously brave. I've heard stories about the prime minister--she hates to be wrong. So you're saying this is why you were suspended?
Papa: The weather in Alorria doesn't cause deaths beyond the mountains. I think you're overreacting. Yes, there has been discussion--
Mother: Lies. The festival doesn't "kill lots of people" [It does.] Storm beasts keep people safe! That's the entire point of celebration! Haven't you read your history?
Gaton: History approved by the prime minister! All weather is connected--the sky is all one piece. You can't dismiss facts just because you don't like where they lead!
Papa: Now, now. I'm sure our government wouldn't deliberately lie. And I'm sure that there's another logical explanation for these "deadly storms."
Mother: If they even exist. Has anyone seen a shred of proof? All I've heard is talk from people who have never even been beyond the mountains. [Mina has been there.]
Gaton: Are you saying Mina's lying?
Papa: Of course no one is saying that.
Mother: I'm saying she's mistaken.
Gaton: She talked with the prime minister!
Mother: But she didn't see any proof--
Gaton: She doesn't need proof, she has logic!
Papa: Let's all calm down.
I don't know about you, but that whole conversation reminds me, well, of the world (country) we live in.
Later, on page 236, Eione, from the other side of the mountain, in not-Alorria says: "You have any idea what it's like to face a killer storm? [a dying economy, war right in your neighborhood, lack of water due to changing weather patterns, extreme heat, starvation--you can replace so many things with killer storm in that question.] No, of course you don't, because in Alorria you only have perfect summer days with mild wind and endless sunshine as you live your perfect, mild lives of endless selfishness."
Wow. Mild lives of endless selfishness. Huh.
On page 262, Mina converses with her teacher, Professor Dano, who is also concerned about the plight of the rest of the world in the face of Alorrian decisions.
Dano: My friends don't believe that children have learned empathy yet. You have at least proved them wrong in that.
Mina: Don't they remember being my age?
Dano: Just the bad parts. Children can be selfish creatures.
Mina: Adults can be worse. (The prime minister and her advisors, after all, were adults. They knew the truth and had the power to do something to help, yet they refused to.)
Dano: I can't argue with that...You must understand that this is about more than one celebration. If the prime minister acknowledges that the festival causes deadly storms beyond the mountains, then it opens the door to change. The prime minister would need to reevaluate every use of storm beasts. If the festival causes harm, what else does? How does keeping our fields perfectly watered affect the ousiders? Examining the effects of our actions could have ramifications throughout the entire economy. Alorria has been prosperous because of its carefully cultivated selfishness. What happens when that crumbles?
Another wow. Carefully cultivated selfishness. Huh.
Back to Eione on page 288:
Eione: I don't want their pity. I want them to stop murdering our people and destroying our homes. [Which they are doing indirectly through the truly savage weather that does indeed kill and destroy.] How's she going to convince them to do that? Look at these people, smug in their wealth, blinded by their excess. What is she going to tell them that's going to compete with all this?
Smug in their wealth. Blinded by their excess. Could this be...us?
Mina has Eione speak--she doesn't do it herself. And one last paragraph from page 291: Just because mountains [borders] surrounded them didn't mean they were separated from the rest of the world. They were part of the world. Their sky was also everyone else's sky.
So much "meat" in this juvenile fiction book! Comments?





















